I bought Scarlet Sparkle because I love red and I needed an odd number when I ordered. I was expecting to be lukewarm about it. I have to say that I love it. Like really, really love it. It's smooth, doesn't eat top coat and has a golden red color as opposed to a cherry red color. It reminds me of Essie Ruby Slippers with that golden red feel - it's not a dupe just a cousin. I put it on and went "Ooo pretty!" and that is always a good sign.